Key Considerations When Using an Answering Service

Business owners often turn to answering services or basic voicemail systems to handle calls when staff are busy or unavailable. In many cases this is a practical solution to avoid missing inquiries. However, some studies indicate an impersonal or poorly executed phone experience can actually cost businesses customers, revenue, and long-term loyalty.

A deep look at customer behavior shows that phone interactions remain crucial, yet many callers abandon calls when they don’t reach a live person or get quick help. Recent research reveals that businesses only answer about 38 percent of inbound calls. Another 38 percent go to voicemail, and nearly a quarter receive no response at all. This means nearly two-thirds of callers fail to connect with a live person in some way.

Why phone responsiveness matters
Although digital channels such as chat and email are rising, many customers still prefer direct conversation for clarity and resolution. Even so, traditional voicemail and generic answering services often fail to meet modern expectations. According to data on voicemail behavior, around 80 percent of callers who reach voicemail don’t leave a message, often because they assume it won’t be heard or followed up with promptly.

Customers still overwhelmingly want phone support. Despite increases in digital communication channels, many people continue to prefer speaking directly with a human when they need help. A 2025 consumer study found that 65 % of Americans prefer using a phone call as their primary method of contacting customer service, and even younger generations like Gen Z and younger Millennials show high preference for voice support with 86 % favoring the phone channel for help. This preference highlights that impersonal or poorly handled answering systems risk alienating a large majority of potential customers who simply want timely, direct conversation and problem-solving.

Call abandonment is a real business risk. A frustrated caller who cannot quickly reach someone is far more likely to hang up and try a competitor rather than wait for a callback. While exact bounce-back percentages vary by industry, the sheer volume of callers who never leave messages suggests countless lost opportunities.

Delays in response can also damage reputation. 90 percent of customers say a quick response is critical when they have a support question, with many defining “quick” as within 10 minutes. If an answering service simply records a message for later return, that may not meet expectations, especially when personalized service could quickly resolve a problem or close a sale. These unmet expectations don’t just lose revenue — they erode trust.

The limits of generic or automated responses
Answering services often rely on standard scripts that are generic by design. Without intimate knowledge of your products, pricing, or policies, an answering agent may unintentionally miscommunicate or provide incomplete information. Even some automated or menu-based phone systems frustrate customers who feel like “just another number.” While specific recent data on script impersonality is less formalized in large industry surveys, customer experience research widely emphasizes that customers prioritize personalized, efficient service across channels.

Alternative channels further emphasize this trend: more customers are choosing live chat, messaging, or other real-time responses because they offer immediate, human interaction without waiting for callbacks.

What businesses can do
Not every business can staff every phone line around the clock. However, turning to answering services without clear standards and tracking can lead to lost calls, missed revenue, and unhappy customers.

Best practices include:

• Setting internal response time standards for callbacks
• Training anyone answering phones on your products, policies, and escalation points
• Monitoring and auditing calls to ensure quality
• Offering alternative contact methods that provide timely human interaction

A practical alternative
For businesses that cannot staff phones at all times, programs like BBB’s Get a Quote offer a way to connect with consumers who are actively shopping for services. This tool helps customers request quotes directly, giving them a faster path to engage your business and reducing reliance on voicemail or impersonal answering services, while still capturing leads you might otherwise miss.

When customers can quickly reach a real person, or at least initiate a clear service request, trust grows, and so does the likelihood of conversion.

About BBB: Since 1912, BBB has been supporting businesses and consumers in its mission of advancing marketplace trust.  BBB is a nonprofit, business-supported organization that sets and upholds high standards for fair and honest business behavior. Most BBB services to consumers are free of charge. BBB provides objective advice, free BBB Business Profiles on more than 5.3 million companies, 11,000 charity reviews, dispute resolution services, alerts and educational information on topics affecting marketplace trust. Visit bbb.org for more information. There are over 100 local, independent BBBs across the United States, Canada and Mexico, including BBB Serving Central East Texas, which was founded in 1985 and serves 19 counties.