Skip to content

CHURCH TITHES SHOULDN’T PAY FOR ABUSERS… THEY NEED PRISON TIME

By JAMES A. MARPLES
********************************************************************
 
I was shocked to read in the news where the Catholic Archdiocese of Los Angeles agrees to pay $800 million dollars (that’s nearly a billion dollars) to victims of clergy sexual abuse. For sure, I deem sex-abuse by clergy and/or the cover-ups of the same, to be a heinous crime that deserves severe punishment.
 
I noticed a headline in the Los Angeles Times on October 21st asking: “Why is L.A.’s disgraced ex-archbishop still a cardinal?” .  Good question!  Mahony’s guilt was so pronounced that his successor, Archbishop Jose Gomez has barred Cardinal Roger  Mahony from ANY public ministry in Los Angeles in 2013, some 11 years ago.  Yet, Mahony’s failures have resulted in the $880 million dollar settlement in 2024. That disgraceful shadow lingers on.
 
The Washington Post opined that Mahony is “lucky not to be in prison”. It has been admitted by the Archdiocese that the sexual offenses and cover-ups lasted over decades. Many of the offenders and victims are dead; while some are still alive.
 
Similar things have occurred in Churches, dioceses, and archdioceses all over the United States.  And, several of those entities have had to file for bankruptcy, include those in Fresno, Sacramento, and others. The Church says it will pay the settlement from “internal funds” and from “insurance”.  So, what are internal funds?  Tithes and Offerings that may have been saved by decades, donated to the Church as an offering to God by completely innocent parishioners or generations before them. I don’t think my grandparents who put, say $5 in the collection-plate back in the 1950s, would be pleased that the money or “interest” they intended for God’s work would be spent to pay for a pedophile priest or bishop or one who had masked justice.
 
Some generations of parishioners donated tithes and offerings to build Cathedrals and for their upkeep/maintenance. Now, many dioceses are selling-off buildings to pay legal fees or judgements. That doesn’t seem right.
 
I think the offending priest or bishop who is found guilty or confesses to doing molestation or covering-it-up by should do prison time.That, would deter a lot of offenders.
 
I agree that victims need compensation.  I don’t want Churches to pass-the-buck  and rely on insurance. When I think of insurance, I think of genuine protection against someone falling on an icy sidewalk and breaking an arm — NOT using insurance to reimburse for sexual sins of a wayward priest.
 
Somebody has to draw the line.  I don’t know how. But, reforms should be made.

Leave a Comment