Skip to content

Legal Claim Against the Customs and Border Protection for Negligence in Cleveland, TX Mass Shooting

October 11, 2024 — Austin, Texas — National Trial Law, through attorneys Jamal K. Alsaffar and Tom Jacob, has filed claims against CBP for its failure to report illegal border crossings of a dangerous individual, resulting in a mass shooting in Cleveland, Texas.

The claim asserts that for over thirty years, federal agencies, including the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), Customs and Border Protection (CBP), and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), have systematically failed to comply with federal law requiring them to report dangerous individuals to the FBI’s National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NICS). These failures allowed thousands of dangerous individuals to gain access to firearms and commit acts of violence, including Francisco Oropeza, the perpetrator of the April 28, 2023, shooting.

Francisco Oropeza, a known and repeat criminal who had been deported from the United States four times between 2009 and 2016, should never have been allowed to re-enter the country or access firearms. However, due to the U.S. Government’s repeated failure to enter his information into the FBI’s NICS database, Oropeza was able to purchase the AR-15 rifle used in the massacre. On the night of the incident, Oropeza fatally shot five people, including Sonia Taibot, her son, and three others, while wounding three more.

National Trial Law filed an administrative claim against the United States Government on behalf of the family of Sonia Argentina Guzman Taibot, one of the victims of the tragic mass shooting. The filing seeks justice for the wrongful death of Sonia Taibot and her son, Daniel Laso Guzman, as well as the catastrophic impact the incident has had on their family. Claims were also filed on behalf of Ramiro Adan Guzman Taibot, Yasmin Elizabeth Rivas Ramos, Jefrinson Josue Rivera Romero, and Diana Velasquez Alvarado (deceased).

“This mass shooting was preventable. If the government had followed its own mandatory procedures, this dangerous individual would never have been able to purchase a firearm, much less possess the assault weapon that took the lives of Sonia and her son. The government’s negligence has devastated this family, and they deserve accountability,” said Mr. Asaffar, attorney for the family.

The filing cites numerous instances where the U.S. Government failed to report Oropeza’s illegal entries into the FBI’s national background check system, a duty mandated by the Gun Control Act and the Brady Handgun Violence Prevention Act. The claim highlights that this systematic failure enabled Oropeza to remain undetected by law enforcement, despite numerous opportunities to prevent him from obtaining weapons.

This case brings to light a long-standing failure by federal agencies to comply with reporting requirements designed to protect the public from dangerous individuals like Oropeza. National Trial Law continues to stand by its commitment to seeking justice for victims and holding the U.S. Government accountable for its actions.

About National Trial Law:

National Trial Law, based in Austin, Texas, is a leading law firm specializing in catastrophic personal injury and wrongful death cases, with a focus on holding the U.S. Government accountable through the Federal Tort Claims Act. The firm has a 50+ year history of advocating for families affected by negligence and fighting for justice on behalf of their clients.

Leave a Comment