Skip to content

Stopping the Entire Public School A-F Accountability System With Frivolous Lawsuits Must Stop!

Bettencourt Aghast at Travis County Judge’s Recent Blockage of the A-F System Ratings Release 

Austin, TX – During the Senate Committee on Education, chaired by Senator Brandon Creighton, Texas  Education Agency Commissioner Mike Morath and Senator Bettencourt discussed ISD lawsuits that  continue to block the TEA release of A-F School Accountability system ratings in 2023 and 2024.  

A Travis County Judge, Daniella Deseta Lyttle of the 261st Civil District Court, issued a temporary  injunction prohibiting the release of TEA’s A-F School Accountability system ratings. Judge Lyttle wrote  that TEA Commissioner Mike Morath and the agency are enjoined from assigning ratings “until this Court  issues a final judgment.” This is a blatant move to circumvent an appeal to the new 15th Court of Appeals.  Lyttle also called the A-F rating system “unlawful, ultra vires conduct that violates Texas law and would  cause probable, imminent, and irreparable injury or harm to Plaintiffs.” 

“Quite frankly Judge Lyttle, the Boards of Trustees, and the School District Superintendents of Pecos-Barstow-Toyah, Crandall, Forney, Fort Stockton, and Kingsville, should be ashamed of  themselves for bringing this lawsuit. We have got to have a functioning A-F System, so why are 29 other school districts joining this frivolous lawsuit?” stated Bettencourt. 

Watch the hearing comments at: https://senate.texas.gov/videoplayer.php?vid=20736&lang=en ,timestamp 1:36:39, between Senator Bettencourt and Commissioner Morath.  

The original plaintiffs, Pecos-Barstow-Toyah ISD, Crandall ISD, Forney ISD, Fort Stockton ISD, and  Kingsville ISD, and the 29 other ISDs in this latest lawsuit are clearly against the A-F rating that is sound  public policy. This lawsuit appeal will go through the newly created 15th Court of Appeals which will handle  all state-related lawsuit appeals. 

“I clarified this issue in 2021 with my SB 1365 that continued the A-F ratings and clarified in law  the actions that would be taken against a school district that received an ‘F’ or ‘D’ rating, allowing  the establishment of a turnaround model for low-performing schools yet still allowing for district  flexibility to address the issues that led to low performance,” stated Senator Bettencourt. 

Parents, students, and Texas taxpayers have to have transparency in the public education system so  they can see the accountability rankings for themselves. 

“I’m tired of having a ‘Groundhog Day’ with these Travis County courts that block A-F year after  year. As I always say, ‘What gets measured gets fixed’, and without being able to measure  school’s performance we don’t know what to fix! This is absolutely a critical component of public  education in the 21st century,” concluded Senator Bettencourt. 

See Texas Education Agency Plaintiffs/Intervenors List attached.  

TEA Lawsuit Plaintiffs pages

Leave a Comment