Revisiting Trans Girls in Women’s Sports
Consider the current federal and state cruel attacks on our trans fellow citizens.
First, trans have been around since the beginning of time as the ancient Hebrew language had names for trans men and women. Currently they represent only 0.5 % of the global population, a significant minority. Being trans is not a choice and it is determined during pregnancy.
Second, trans persons have traditionally been attacked, even murdered in some Asian and African countries; nevertheless, they are honored by Native American Indians.
Third, trans folks in America have for years stayed in hiding out of fear, and once they have come out to be who they are, our state and national governments have taken unjustified harmful actions against them including prohibiting lifesaving affirming care, personal rights, and even claiming that they do not exit.
Let’s consider the issues.
First for decades, doctors in USA and around the world have quietly provided the same “puberty delay” for trans as they do for anyone with early onset of puberty. Now, the scientifically proven medically necessary care is prohibited for trans persons.
Second, for decades and continuing, doctors have provided physical surgical procedures for men and women wanting to appear more male or female; yet that treatment is now taken away from trans persons even after the mandated age of 18. Keep in mind that some persons are born gender-diverse with both male and female genitalia and may require genital surgery at some point.
Third, science now documents that gender affirming care, including counseling and puberty delaying treatment prior to age 18, is lifesaving. It promotes wellbeing and reduces suicide among trans persons.
Lastly, genital surgeries are not performed until after age 18, and then only at the request or even demand of the trans person who knows best who they are and what they need to feel right.
Dealing with the issue of youth athletics, there is much mis- and dis-information about the issue. The actual number of trans girls who want to participate in youth sports is very few. Deciding who plays youth sports should be managed at the local level respecting individual needs and rights, as well as community benefit.
Consider that a trans woman treated at onset of puberty, would receive treatment delaying puberty and decreasing male hormones along with replacement female hormones. That treatment stops the male body building process. Therefore, a trans woman is not likely to be as strong as a male. Further, many women or girls may be stronger than males because we all receive various amounts of both male and female hormones.
We need to end the war on trans persons in our civilization and seek to care for one another.
Lolly Lockhart PhD RN
References include:
National Geographic, January 2017 Scientific American, August 2017
The World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) Standards of Care (SOC) are evidence-based guidelines for the medical care of transgender and gender-diverse individuals. They provide a framework for healthcare providers to ensure that these individuals receive safe, compassionate and culturally competent care.
