Dollars and Sense – Michael W Marshall; Community Banker
Overpayment Scam
Here we are at the start of the holiday season; and if you are like me, I’m still trying to recoup all the money I spent over the last couple of months. Sure, I’m doing some of the usual like trying not to eat out all the time and not going to the grocery store on an empty stomach. But I’m also starting to clean up and organize to see what I can sale for a quick profit. I’ve got some homeowner hand tools way in the back of my shed that I haven’t used in I don’t know when. I thought that it would be great if I could sell those tools to get some quick cash to help replenish my bank account.
So here’s what I did. I pulled those tools out of the shed, knocked off the spider webs, polished them up, took pictures, and placed them up for sale on the Facebook Marketplace for $350 (I mean, these are some nice, barely used tools).
Before long, I had a couple of people asking me more questions about the tools. Then I had a guy say he was buying them and sending me a cashier’s check for the tools, so he wanted me to take the post down.
In just a few days, I received a cashier’s check in the amount of $750! Wait a minute, I was only selling them for $350 dollars, this person overpaid me for $400! So I reached out to the person asking what was going on. Once I got him on the phone he was so embarrassed and told me that he was purchasing multiple items off of Facebook Marketplace and must of got the price of my hand tools mixed up with another one of his purchases.
Well, that seems like an honest mistake. To correct the mistake, the man told me to keep an extra $50 for my troubles, but then to send him back $350 so that he can send the money on to who was supposed to receive it. He was going to come by over the next weekend to pick up the tools. So instead of selling the tools for $350, I sold them for $400, I couldn’t get to the bank quickly enough to cash the cashier’s check that he sent me.
Once I had sent him back the excess $350, within 2 days my bank was calling me frantically on the phone. The $750 cashier’s check that was sent to me, that I cashed 2 days ago, charged back to my account as fraudulent! I had been dupped and now I owe the bank $750! Naturally I tried calling the man who was buying my tools, but his phone had been disconnected, and his Facebook profile had been deleted too! So my next stop was the local police department; but they told me that this was a common scam and that there was no way that I would be able to recover any of the money.
Come to find out, I was victim of an Overpayment Scam. The way it works is that people selling items via the internet or local paper are approached by a potential buyer with an offer. The seller, potential victim, receives a negotiable item usually in the form of a counterfeit cashier’s check for an amount higher than the purchase price. The potential victim is then instructed to send the balance of the funds back to the buyer or to a 3rd party shipping company. Not only are the funds not good; if shipped, the sold item is lost also.
For a more detailed overview of scams used, visit https://consumer.ftc.gov/articles/how-spot-avoid-and-report-fake-check-scams
So, with all this gloom and doom talk, how do we stop the overpayment scam? The answer is simple…Know what you received and from whom.
- If you receive an unsolicited letter containing a check or money order that you know nothing about, then you need to question it.
- A lot of the scams are being mailed from Canada. If the envelope was mailed from out of state or Canada, then this should be an indicator that this could be a scam.
- Pay attention to the item. Is the item drawn from an out of state bank? Are there misspelled words on the check?
- Do not contact the person or company that issued you the item by a phone number on the letter. These scams work by having the potential victim contact the con-artist, which opens up a line of communication.
- Contact the bank where the check is drawn from. Don’t use the phone number on the check. If the check in hand is a counterfeit then any phone number on the check is a fake number also…use a web search such as www.dogpile.com to find a phone number.
- Talk to your financial institution. Explain to them that you know nothing about the item other than it was mailed to you. Be sure to bring the item, envelope, and all other correspondence you received.
- You can contact your local police department or the post office for more information on scams.
Remember to be cautious with promises of getting something for nothing and of any unsolicited letters you may receive. If you do receive an unsolicited check or money order that sounds like it could be a scam, then contact your financial institution, police department, or post office.
Michael W Marshall
Proud Community Banker
