Skip to content

Republicans spent years remaking Texas courts in their image. Voters unraveled it in one election.

By Eleanor Klibanoff and Alex Nguyen, The Texas Tribune
November 17, 2026

Over the last three decades, as Texas Republicans’ grip on power grew ever stronger, state leaders reimagined the highest courts in their image.

Through hand-picked appointments, Gov. Greg Abbott remade the Texas Supreme Court. Backing primary challengers, Attorney General Ken Paxton reshaped the Court of Criminal Appeals to oust judges who had ruled against him. Texas lawmakers created a new appellate court, stocked with GOP judges, to hear challenges to state laws.

With federal courts leaning increasingly conservative, Texas Republicans were on the cusp of never having to plead their case before a liberal judge again.

And then came the blue wave. When Democrats swept every statewide seat on the Texas ballot, they also radically reshaped the judicial branch, disrupting conservatives’ long-term project on the courts.

Four Supreme Court justices lost their seats, including the chief justice, an Abbott acolyte who will be replaced by the first woman and first out LGBTQ+ person to head the court. Three Democrats were elected to the Court of Criminal Appeals, and the new 15th Court of Appeals flipped entirely from three Republicans to three Democrats.

The political implications are stark, loosening Republicans’ stranglehold on interpreting the Texas Constitution, deciding high-profile death penalty cases and hearing challenges to state laws.

“I would anticipate seeing a tremendous flood of money and special-interest attention as these courts become a huge source of contestation in not only 2028, but presumably elections to come,” said Alicia Bannon, senior director of the Brennan Center’s judiciary program.

How these elections will influence actual court rulings remains to be seen. While judicial philosophy does often fall along partisan lines, and the newly elected judges have at times clashed with the high courts they will occupy, court watchers anticipate outcomes to shift slowly, in ways that may initially be imperceptible to the public.

Gisela Triana, an Austin-based appellate judge who was elected to the Texas Supreme Court, said she’s heard from people who seemed to think that four Democratic justices could restore abortion rights overnight.

“And I had to tell them, ‘I think you’re confused on how this works,’” she said with a laugh. “There’s a big building over there where people are elected to make those decisions. We’re not the branch of the government that sets policy.”

The nine GOP justices on the Supreme Court often disagreed among themselves, and Triana and other incoming judges say they anticipate the same will be true with judges from their party.

“For people who want to know what’s going to change, I’d say come back this time next year,” said Adam Shniderman, a lawyer at Alexander Dubose Jefferson who worked as a clerk and staff attorney at the Texas Supreme Court. “There’s a bunch of opinions on what [the newly elected judges] are going to do on the court, but at this point it’s just reading the tea leaves.”

Supreme Court of Texas

A year and a half ago, Supreme Court Chief Justice Jimmy Blacklock stood before the GOP-dominated Texas Legislature and declared that state judges would be expected to closely adhere to the original meaning of the state’s foundational texts.

“This is called constitutional originalism, and under this Supreme Court, it is the law in Texas,” Blacklock said in his State of the Judiciary speech to cheers from lawmakers. “Under this Supreme Court, the living constitution is dead.”

But like a zombie hand rising from the grave, the living constitution has found new life after the Nov. 3 election, where Blacklock lost his seat to Maggie Ellis, a justice on the Austin-based 3rd Court of Appeals.

“At the time the laws were being made,” Ellis said, “they were being made by a very homogenous group of wealthy white landowners, all men, and I think some of the laws were written in a way that didn’t reflect or respect or see the other citizens of Texas,” Ellis said.

Ellis said she is not a constitutional originalist, a judicial philosophy more closely associated with conservative jurists. She believes there are rare cases where judges must interpret the law “in a way that reflects where society is.”

“But I will underline — very rare,” she said.

She pointed to Obergefell v. Hodges, the U.S. Supreme Court case that allowed same sex marriage in all 50 states. Without that 2015 ruling, Ellis, the first out member of the high court, would not have been able to get married in Texas.

The Texas Supreme Court is the final arbiter of consequential questions about state law, the power of government officials and the Texas Constitution. While it handles a wide array of issues, it gets the most attention for a small portion of cases on high-profile issues like abortion, LGBTQ rights and redistricting.

These are the cases where four new justices with new judicial philosophies seem most likely to make a difference. But it’s hard to say how that will translate into specific rulings, especially with the Democratic justices making up a narrow minority. The court is constrained by what cases are brought before it, and while it takes only four justices to agree to hear a case, it’s unlikely they’d take on a controversial issue if they couldn’t see the possibility of getting a fifth vote on their side.

Shniderman said it’s premature to predict which judges are likely to be a swing vote on any specific type of case, and he anticipated most of that negotiating to happen out of the public eye. The Texas Supreme Court has historically prided itself on being collegial and less fiery than its federal counterpart, and he doesn’t expect that to change.

“Judges are by their nature conservative, not in the political sense but in that they don’t love big sweeping changes,” he said. “Precedent makes the world they operate in easier, so I think we can expect them to be circumspect and cautious.”

One area where four new faces are predicted to have an impact is on civil court verdicts. Over decades of Republican dominance, the Supreme Court has developed a reputation for knocking down high-dollar civil judgments awarded against corporations by juries and judges.

“There has been a perception that a really big judgment was dead on arrival in the Texas Supreme Court, an understanding so prevalent on both sides of the bar that it influenced a lot of court settlement decisions,” said Christopher Kratovil, a lawyer with Dykema who has argued before the Supreme Court dozens of times. “The analogy is that on the defense side of the bar, we’ve had the best goalie in the world. Now, it seems likely we’ll have more of a replacement-level goalie — some stuff will get through.”

A politically divided court is not necessarily a bad thing, Kratovil said. It will actually bring the state closer to the norm.

“I haven’t had one Democratic Supreme Court justice for one minute of one case for the entire quarter-century I’ve been in practice,” he said. “That’s the oddity, that it’s been so monolithic.”

Texas Court of Criminal Appeals

The seismic electoral shift ended Paxton’s project to remake the state’s highest criminal court, an effort that led to significant turnover on the nine-judge panel over the past few years.

The churn started when Paxton — who cast himself as an election integrity champion — worked to unseat the eight Republican judges who in 2021 ruled that his office lacked the authority to independently prosecute allegations of voter fraud. His campaign ousted three incumbents in 2024, wiping out nearly a century of criminal law experience from a court that hears death penalty appeals, challenges to state criminal laws and petitions from a wide variety of criminal cases.

This year, two more incumbents from that 2021 decision decided not to seek reelection.

On the other hand, Republican Judge Kevin Yeary — the lone dissenter — cruised through the primary without a challenger. He and a Paxton-endorsed newcomer also significantly outraised their Democratic opponents before Election Day.

Then, the blue wave swept three Democrats onto the court and Yeary out of office.

After the election, Yeary said he hadn’t anticipated that the 2021 ruling would lead to a political firestorm. Instead, the judge said he dissented because he thought his colleagues were wrong.

“Some of my good friends on the court lost their jobs after that Stephens case,” he added. “But also, the court at the same time gained some really terrific jurists.”

Meanwhile, Republican lawmakers passed a law last year giving the attorney general the power to unilaterally prosecute election crimes, but they did so by updating the Election Code rather than by pushing for a constitutional amendment. The Texas District and County Attorneys Association questioned whether the change was enough, saying “only litigation” would provide the answer.

There has yet to be a court case to test the law, TDCAA’s Executive Director Shannon Edmonds said. Attorney General-elect Nathan Johnson opposed the measure as a state senator.

It remains to be seen how the court’s impending 6-3 partisan split will influence its many decisions.

“The reality is nobody knows because the challenge with judicial campaigning is that many of them are reluctant to give specifics on particular issues, and some of that is a result of the judicial canons [of ethics],” Edmonds said. “It’s also sometimes a handy excuse for them to not show their cards, even if ethically or legally they could.”

Ben Wolff, who as director of the Office of Capital and Forensic Writs advocates for people sentenced to death or whose convictions involved flawed forensic science, said a judge’s political party is “a very imperfect proxy” for how they would rule.

“I’ve practiced in front of a lot of really good Republican judges and a lot of bad Republican judges, and I’ve practiced in front of some good Democratic judges and some really bad Democratic judges,” Wolff said in a statement. “It’s the diversity of experience, perspective, and commitment to fairness that will be important.”

Some court watchers are hoping the turnover will bolster one important issue: actual innocence claims by convicted people seeking exoneration and state compensation. Simply having a conviction overturned does not automatically lead to compensation because, according to court precedent, claimants must “show by clear and convincing evidence that no reasonable juror would have convicted [them] in light of new evidence.”

Among the outgoing judges, Texas Monthly reported, Yeary has led the push for a high bar in granting actual innocence claims.

Yeary told The Texas Tribune that there is a difference between concluding that someone would not be convicted based on new evidence and declaring that they literally did not commit the crime. Using the right word to convey the court’s requirements and findings matters, he said.

“And if we do not think that a jury would find a person guilty now, then we should indeed say that they have restored their ‘presumption of innocence,’” the judge added in a statement. “On the other hand, if a person was required to prove that they actually did not do the crime before being declared ‘actually innocent,’ in that circumstance even I might say that the person is ‘actually innocent’ if they have actually proved that to be true.”

Actual innocence claims are also a top issue for incoming judges.

Judge-elect Holly Taylor has often highlighted her work investigating wrongful convictions as part of the Travis County district attorney’s office. Now, she wants to push for a more thorough review of these petitions.

“I believe that addressing wrongful convictions not only ensures that we are doing justice … but also that we are holding the truly dangerous and guilty people accountable who may be at large, who may be committing additional crimes,” Taylor said. “This is something that’s very important to me, and we’re going to begin conversations probably very, very soon.”

Judge Audra Riley, who defeated Yeary and will be the first Black woman to serve on the state’s highest criminal court, also said she considers wrongful convictions and actual innocence claims to be major issues.

But both Democrats emphasized that future decisions will depend on the facts of each case — a position that also applies to death penalty appeals.

“I would follow what the law says in Texas,” said Riley, who currently presides over Dallas County Criminal District Court No. 3. “I was a prosecutor and defense attorney, so I see both arguments, and so I have to just take it case by case.”

15th Court of Appeals

The blue tsunami also flipped the entire statewide 15th Court of Appeals, which GOP lawmakers created in 2023 to address concerns from Abbott, Paxton and other conservatives who felt challenges to state laws were not getting a fair shake in the Austin-based appeals court where they frequently ended up.

While supporters said the new court would boost judicial efficiency and expertise, critics viewed it as a way to sidestep Democratic judges who dominate elections in big, urban counties.

Abbott appointed the first three judges, all Republicans, but they didn’t always toe the party line. The judges ruled against Paxton in several high-profile cases, criticizing the attorney general’s office at times for bringing thin, partisan cases.

When Democrats left the state to deny the Legislature the quorum needed to pass a new, more GOP-friendly congressional map, Paxton argued in an explosive lawsuit that former U.S. Rep. Beto O’Rourke had engaged in bribery, fraud and campaign finance violations by supporting wayward Democrats. When the 15th Court ruled against Paxton, he lashed out on social media, saying the “Beto-loving” court made a “blindly political attempt” to help the Democrat.

Justices also criticized Paxton’s office for failing to present evidence in a case over whether the attorney general has the right to demand records from local district attorneys.

After the election, the Republican incumbents canceled oral arguments in four cases that were initially set for early December, including one challenging state rules cracking down on hemp-derived THC products, leaving the cases for the incoming Democrats.

It remains to be seen how the new judges will change the court and what kind of cases the Democrats will encounter during their six-year terms.

“There are a lot of things that are hard to predict right now just because it depends on the case and controversy that gets brought,” said Judge-elect Marc Meyer. “And I couldn’t give you an answer on anything specific anyway because it depends on what the facts of the cases are and how the statutes and laws of the state are written.”

For now, the Democrat said, he will bring a new viewpoint based on his background as a retired paramedic and registered nurse whose current work as a lawyer focuses on representing those in medical industries.

“If there is a big change, it’s going to be looking at how individuals are treated by the state,” Meyer said.

Looking forward, the court will add two new justices in 2027. Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa will get to make those appointments, cementing the Democratic hold on the panel.

Disclosure: Texas Monthly has been a major financial supporter of The Texas Tribune. The Texas Tribune is a nonprofit, nonpartisan news organization that is funded in part by donations from members, foundations and corporate sponsors. Financial supporters play no role in our journalism. Find a complete list of them and more information about our financial and disclosure policies here.

This article first appeared on The Texas Tribune. 

Leave a Comment