Skip to content

Gilmer 49, Carthage 42

By Joe Dodd

GILMER — Ninety-five yards stood between Gilmer and one of the most memorable victories in the storied history of Buckeye football.
With the score tied at 42, with just 2:46 remaining and the football resting at their own 5-yard line, the Buckeyes faced the daunting task of driving the length of the field against a Carthage team that had won 38 consecutive games.
Seven plays later, senior Aiden Thomas raced 40 yards for the winning touchdown, sending a packed Jeff Traylor Stadium into a frenzy and lifting Gilmer to a thrilling 49-42 victory Friday night over the two-time defending Class 4A Division II state champions.
The victory ended two remarkable Carthage winning streaks. The Bulldogs had won 38 consecutive games overall and 55 straight district contests, dating to a 41-34 loss to Kilgore on Oct. 7, 2016.
But even after Thomas’ touchdown with 48 seconds remaining, the Buckeyes still had work to do.
Carthage returned the ensuing kickoff 43 yards to the Gilmer 30, giving the Bulldogs one final opportunity to extend the game. Gilmer’s defense forced three consecutive incompletions before an offsides penalty gave Carthage fourth-and-5 at the 25.
Quarterback Jacob Dixon’s final pass fell incomplete with 15 seconds remaining, and Gilmer ran out the clock to secure the victory.
Gilmer coach Alan Metzel said his players had approached the game with the proper mentality.
“I thought they played loose. I thought they played confident. They were on the attack,” Metzel said. “They went to go win the game.”
The Buckeyes improved to 7-2 overall and 3-1 in District 8-4A Division II, while Carthage fell to 7-1 and 3-1.
For Gilmer, the victory represented another chapter in a rivalry between two of Texas’ most successful programs. The Buckeyes also defeated Carthage 47-44 in overtime in the 2023 state quarterfinals, ending a 29-game Bulldog winning streak on their way to the state championship.
Metzel, however, said ending Carthage’s streaks was not what motivated the Buckeyes.
“I really don’t think about that too much, just because I had nothing to do with that,” he said. “I try and think of what we can control.”
Instead, Metzel pointed to months of preparation and the satisfaction of seeing his players execute against one of the state’s premier programs.
“I’m thrilled for our town because this is such an exciting thing for the town,” he said. “I was getting something to eat Saturday, and people are honking horns and waving and yelling, and that’s fun to be a part of because everybody is a part of that.”
A sign of things to come
The game’s opening possessions offered an early indication of the offensive showdown that was about to unfold.
Carthage took the opening kickoff and methodically marched 70 yards in 10 plays, consuming 4:19 before taking a 7-0 lead.
Gilmer’s response could hardly have been more different.
The Buckeyes covered the same 70 yards in just three plays and 62 seconds, with quarterback Zade Taylor connecting with freshman Kaden Canady on a 36-yard touchdown pass to tie the game at 7-7.
Beyond answering Carthage’s opening score, the touchdown served an important strategic purpose by forcing the Bulldogs to adjust their defensive alignment.
“To start the game, their safeties are lined up at five yards,” Metzel said. “So we’re like, ‘Okay, let’s go,’ and we threw over the top, and you hit it. Well, now they’re back at 10.”
Moving the safeties five yards deeper created additional room for Gilmer’s running backs.
“That’s a big difference in being able to stop the run,” Metzel said. “They may make the tackle, but it is probably five or six yards instead of at three. So that type of ability, you got to do just enough to get them out of there.”
Those opening possessions established the game’s rhythm. Carthage repeatedly put together sustained drives, while Gilmer countered with explosive plays and remarkable offensive efficiency.
Neighbors answers the call
Gilmer entered the game without leading rusher Trayveon Horne, who was sidelined by an injury.
A week earlier against Center, the Buckeyes had compensated by spreading carries among numerous players, rushing for 345 yards without an individual 100-yard rusher.
Against Carthage, the plan was different.
Gilmer put the football in the hands of junior Kipton Neighbors, and he responded with one of the most impressive performances of his career.
Neighbors rushed for 241 yards and 4 touchdowns on 22 carries, averaging 11 yards per attempt. His scoring runs covered 2, 27, 70 and 21 yards.
“We planned to give it to him,” Metzel said. “He was going to carry it like Tayveon would have. That was the plan.”
Metzel said the approach against Center had been intentional, but the Carthage game demanded something different.
“The other night, that was one where it was time Kip had to carry it, and man, he just flourished,” he said.
The coach emphasized that Neighbors’ contributions went far beyond his rushing statistics.
He recalled a play on which Neighbors delivered a devastating block on a linebacker while quarterback Zade Taylor carried the ball.
“There’s so much more to that position, like knowing where to go in his pass protections,” Metzel said. “We had these past two weeks where we had to really grind on details of the position, and he stays after practice and makes sure he knows his assignments.”
Metzel said Neighbors welcomed the responsibility.
“He likes having the pressure on him. So that didn’t faze him,” he said. “I think he was pretty excited about getting an opportunity to get the ball and to go see what he could do, and he went out and balled out.”
Quarterback Zade Taylor added 116 rushing yards on 15 carries, including a 58-yard run, and completed six of seven passes for 74 yards and a touchdown.
Thomas contributed 40 yards on his only carry.
Gilmer finished with 397 rushing yards on 39 attempts, averaging 10.2 yards per carry against a Carthage defense that entered the game allowing an average of just 121 rushing yards and 18.3 points per game.
Metzel credited the offensive line’s physicality and ability to adjust to Carthage’s defensive movements.
“Our line continues to grow in their tenacity and their cohesion,” he said. “There were a lot of blocks where you were seeing guys being moved downfield from the offensive line, and that’s a good feeling, to feel like you can move the line of scrimmage forward.”
Ninety-five yards to victory
The final drive provided the defining moment of the night.
After Carthage tied the game at 42 on JD Edwards’ 4-yard touchdown run with 2:46 remaining, Gilmer found itself pinned at its own 5 following a penalty on the kickoff return.
Metzel said the key was avoiding the temptation to think about the entire distance to the end zone.
“You want to get to the first first down. That’s the critical thing,” he said. “So the critical point is go get the first down, get that done, go from there.”
Neighbors gained 5 yards on first down and 8 on second down. Taylor then completed a 6-yard pass to freshman Kaden Canady before picking up another first down with a 4-yard run.
After Taylor lost 3 yards, Gilmer faced second-and-13 at its own 25.
Neighbors broke through for 35 yards to the Carthage 40.
Metzel believed Gilmer’s physical running game had begun to take its toll on the Bulldog defense.
“By that point we had worn on them,” he said. “There had been a whole lot of hitting up there in that front, and at that time you’ve done what you want to do in that you’ve pushed that needle over, and they’re tired.”
On the next play, Gilmer turned to senior Aiden Thomas, bringing fresh legs and exceptional speed into the backfield on what would become the game-winning touchdown.
Thomas, a team captain who primarily plays safety, took the handoff, spotted an opening and cut back through a hole created by the offensive line.
“The O-line ripped a big hole,” Metzel said. “But to Aiden’s credit, Aiden read the way the block went and bends it back to the opening, and then he can run.”
Thomas, the lead leg on Gilmer’s sprint relay team, outran the Carthage defenders for a 40-yard touchdown that put the Buckeyes ahead 49-42 with 48 seconds remaining.
“He’s such a great teammate, a great young man, and excited for him that he got to make that statement play,” Metzel said.
Two stops make the difference
While Gilmer’s offense produced 471 yards and scored on all eight possessions, the Buckeye defense delivered two critical stops against a Carthage offense that entered the game averaging nearly 49 points.
The first came early in the second quarter.
With the game tied 14-14, Carthage had driven to the Gilmer 7 and faced second-and-goal.
Gilmer’s Mayson McDonald broke through and sacked Dixon for a 16-yard loss, forcing a fumble that Aaden Borelly-Brown recovered at the Gilmer 23.
The Buckeyes then drove 77 yards and scored on Neighbors’ 27-yard touchdown run to take their first lead, 21-14.
Metzel said the play was the result of all 11 defenders executing their assignments.
“On the first part of the play everyone was covered.” Metzel said. “So then he has to start looking to his secondary people. That’s when Mason sees an opening and cuts through.”
McDonald pursued Dixon, grabbed his legs and forced the fumble.
“There’s Aaden, and there you go,” Metzel said. “It was one of those things where all 11 people did their job, and then Mayson made the big play, and Aaden got the fumble recovery.”
The second defensive stop came on Carthage’s final possession.
Despite starting at the Gilmer 30, the Bulldogs failed to gain a yard through the air on four attempts. The only advancement came on Gilmer’s offsides penalty.
Metzel praised his secondary for forcing difficult throws.
“I thought our guys did a good job in the secondary being there,” he said. “They made them have to make a play, and in that moment they didn’t.”
Carthage finished with 425 total yards on 67 offensive plays, meaning the Bulldogs ran 21 more plays but finished with 46 fewer yards.
Carthage also held the ball for 26:17 compared with Gilmer’s 21:43.
Metzel said his defense deserved recognition for continuing to battle despite the Bulldogs’ offensive success.
“We were playing the number one team in the state, who has won 11 state championships, and we fought and battled and got a stop in the first half,” he said. “We got a stop in the second half, and it was what we needed to win the game.”
Zaylen Johnson led Gilmer with 11 tackles, while Borelly-Brown recorded 10 and McDonald nine.
Fourth downs and a sophomore kicker
Neither team punted in a game where fourth-down decisions repeatedly influenced the outcome.
Gilmer converted all three fourth-down opportunities, while Carthage converted three of four. The Bulldogs’ only failure came on their final offensive play.
In the first quarter, Neighbors gained 4 yards on fourth-and-1 at the Carthage 6, setting up his 2-yard touchdown run.
Later, a Carthage offsides penalty on fourth-and-3 extended a Gilmer possession that ended with Neighbors’ 27-yard touchdown.
Late in the first half, Taylor connected with Canady for 13 yards on fourth-and-11 at the Carthage 45. The Buckeyes eventually reached the Carthage 13, where sophomore Alan Sanchez kicked a 30-yard field goal with 15 seconds remaining to give Gilmer a 24-22 halftime lead.
Metzel said the pace of the game influenced his willingness to gamble on fourth down.
“I’d rather take that chance than just kick it and take the chance that they’re not going to score,” he said. “If I was playing somebody who wasn’t as prolific in scoring, I might not do that, but in that type of a game, I felt like I had to make that decision and go.”
Sanchez added a 29-yard field goal on Gilmer’s opening possession of the second half, extending the lead to 27-22.
Remarkably, Gilmer had not attempted a field goal all season, making Sanchez’s two successful kicks the first varsity field goal attempts of his career.
Metzel said he never hesitated to trust the sophomore.
“Inside the 15, we do that every week in practice and he’s money,” Metzel said. “It’s like an extra point to him. I felt very confident when I sent him out, I didn’t think a single thing negative about it.”
Sanchez also converted all five of his extra-point kicks, finishing with 11 points.
The two field goals and Taylor’s successful two-point conversion following Neighbors’ 70-yard touchdown run proved especially important in a seven-point victory.
“When you factor in the two field goals and going for it once, that’s seven points,” Metzel said. “We won by seven points.”
A victory to build upon
The Buckeyes scored on every possession, committed no turnovers and finished with 10.2 yards per offensive play.
Metzel called it Gilmer’s most efficient offensive performance of the season.
“We hit every single one of our offensive objectives; every marker from scoring in the red zone to completion percentage to averaging over four yards to explosives,” he said. “Every single one of them we hit, and that’s about all you can ask.”
The coach said Friday’s victory would become meaningful beyond the immediate celebration only if his players use it to improve.
He pointed to three objectives entering the Carthage game: winning the turnover battle, playing physically and taking the game to the Bulldogs rather than waiting for mistakes.
Gilmer accomplished all three.
“If we’ll carry that forward, then it will be proven to become that catalyst,” Metzel said.
For Gilmer, Friday night will remain unforgettable. But Metzel hopes the victory will be remembered for more than ending two remarkable Carthage winning streaks.
The Buckeyes have their sights set on a much bigger prize, and their coach believes they have the potential to compete for it.
“I felt like this team could push for a state championship,” Metzel said. “Do I think that we’ve arrived at that place? No, I don’t.”
The victory over Carthage demonstrated what Gilmer is capable of accomplishing. Now the challenge is to build on it when the stakes grow even higher in the postseason.

https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1Euh4NFsxo/

https://www.facebook.com/reel/1485992083454052

Gilmer 49, Carthage 42: Buckeyes End Bulldogs’ 38-Game Winning Streak

GILMER, Texas: The Gilmer Buckeyes ended the top-ranked Carthage Bulldogs’ 38-game winning streak Friday night, beating them 49-42 at Jeff Traylor Stadium. Kipton Neighbors ran for four touchdowns in the win over the No. 1 Bulldogs. The loss ended Carthage’s perfect season. The Bulldogs had not lost this year and came in as the defending-dynasty favorite. Gilmer had not beaten Carthage at home since 2011, according to pregame notes.

Key Moments

  1. Carthage strikes first. The Bulldogs took a 7-0 lead on a 10-play, 70-yard drive that ended with a 2-yard quarterback sneak by Jacob Dixon.
  2. Taylor to Canady ties it. Gilmer pulled even on a 36-yard touchdown pass from Zade Taylor to Kaden Canady.
  3. Halftime lead on a rare field goal. A 30-yard field goal by Alan Sanchez, Gilmer’s first field goal attempt of the season, put the Buckeyes up 24-22 at the break with 13 seconds left in the half.
  4. Carthage answers. A 30-yard touchdown pass from Dixon to Bundy put the Bulldogs back in front, 28-27, with 3:13 left in the third quarter.
  5. Neighbors takes over. With starting running back Tayveon Horne out with an injury, Neighbors moved to running back and finished with 22 carries for 241 yards and four touchdowns. He had been better known as a receiver and defender this season. He came in with 19 catches for 307 yards and two touchdowns.
  6. Thomas delivers the winner. Gilmer’s Aiden Thomas scored the winning touchdown on a 40-yard run.
  7. Closing it out. The Buckeyes took a knee three times to finish off the victory.

By the Numbers

  • Carthage ground game: Eight different ball carriers combined for 254 rushing yards on 47 attempts.
  • Records: Gilmer improves to 7-2 overall and 3-1 in district, while Carthage falls to 7-1 and 3-1.

Up Next

Gilmer visits Spring Hill (3-6, 1-3) next Friday, while Carthage hosts winless Center.

Claude

 

Leave a Comment