| Judge grants motion for summary judgment, stopping case short of trial
(Austin, TX) – Texas Health Care Association (THCA) celebrates Monday’s court ruling granting summary judgment in the lawsuit against the Biden Administration’s staffing mandate for nursing homes issued by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) in 2024. This decision vacates the staffing requirements in CMS’s rule that was set to go into effect next month.
The CMS rule, if implemented, would have required nursing homes to meet onerous staffing ratios. Amid widespread staffing shortages and escalating recruitment challenges across the long-term care sector, this would put many facilities at risk of closure. With today’s summary judgment, the judge determined there was no need for a trial because the facts clearly showed the rule could not stand under the law.
“This ruling is a win for common sense and for the seniors and families who depend on access to care in their communities,” said Travis Clardy, President and CEO of THCA. “The staffing mandate, which never received Congressional approval, was simply unworkable in today’s labor environment. Skilled caregivers are in short supply, and forcing facilities to meet arbitrary minimums would have resulted in mass closures of facilities—not because they weren’t committed to care, but because the workforce, especially in rural Texas, often just doesn’t exist.”
THCA and its member facilities have consistently supported efforts to improve staffing and care quality but emphasized that a one-size-fits-all federal mandate fails to account for geographic disparities, rural workforce constraints, and the unique challenges faced by individual providers.
“Texas providers are doing everything they can to recruit and retain caregivers, and this ruling affirms what we’ve been saying all along—solutions must be realistic, flexible, and centered on outcomes, not quotas,” said Clardy. “We urge our Congressional delegation to take action to permanently block these sorts of mandates going forward, and we look forward to working with them and our state-level partners to build long-term workforce solutions to better serve the families that rely on these facilities.”
Clardy also expressed THCA’s gratitude for the co-plaintiffs in the case, saying, “I want to extend my sincere thanks to the Booker Hospital District, and affiliates of HMG Healthcare, Arborbrook Plaza and Harbor Lakes Nursing & Rehabilitation Center for their steadfast resolve in defeating this burdensome regulation and their exemplary commitment to providing quality care to Texans.”
ABOUT THCA
Texas Health Care Association (THCA) was founded to unite, represent, and support professionals who strive to improve the delivery, quality, and integrity of long-term healthcare services.
In service of this mission, THCA works to develop and participate in efforts to improve and measure the quality of long-term healthcare services, to advocate for a fair enforcement and litigation environment in which providers can meet the needs of their residents, to advocate for appropriate funding for resident well-being, to provide education about the long-term care profession, to build consumer alliances and regulatory partnerships, and to continually refine and develop membership services that meet the needs of both state and national association members. |