Senate Bill 2 Floor Debate
Senator Creighton called me a liar on the Senate floor, me and all the Texans who are screaming that ESA’s will destroy public education in Texas, that billionaires are financing this push, and that the ultimate goal is to privatize the education system; he claims we are creating a narrative.
The thing is, that is literally what Jeff Yass has said his plan is, which is to create a free-market so that failing government schools close. The right has a really hard time discerning propaganda from fact, shoring up their debate with sources from an organization founded by an economist who defended the segregation of schools, Milton Friedman.
Treating public education like a free-market capitalist experiment is ignoring the challenges educators face. We don’t live in an Ayn Rand novel and Texas isn’t a philosophical capitalist utopian dream. Who is going to take the dumb kids? The ones with behavior issues? The disabled? The poor?
Public schools struggle because they don’t have the luxury of rejecting the students who make education more difficult. Of course, private schools have better outcomes, they literally get to pick who the accept. And once they’ve siphoned off the best and brightest, what will be left at our public schools?
Will there be a great private school to deal with all the average kids in a given zip code? Taught by the average teachers who couldn’t get hired by the private schools? That’s free-market capitalism, right? Look what privatization has done to healthcare and health insurance. Is anyone pleased with those results?
Society benefits from a well-educated population; we all benefit when our schools are good. Can our lawmakers focus on improving the public schools they are responsible for, rather than siphoning money off for students to escape them? Telling Texans that our schools are bad, and that is why we need school choice, is a pretty remarkable argument coming from the men and women whom we elected to make sure that our schools are good.
If our lawmakers can’t improve our public schools perhaps, we need new lawmakers. The ESA is the initial first step of the endgame of free-market education, privatized, an experiment from the mind of libertarians, where are children are the rats.
