HENRY HYDE’S MONUMENTS
By Paul F. Petrick
“Petty.” “Divisive.” “
Best known for his sixteen terms in the U.S. House of Representatives, Hyde did not discover his true vocation until middle age. It was only after helping Georgetown University’s basketball team reach the NCAA championship game, serving in the U.S. Navy during World War II, spending decades in Chicago’s Naval Intelligence Reserve unit achieving the rank of commander, entertaining audiences as a stand-up comedian, and advocating for clients as a successful lawyer and for constituents as a state legislator did Hyde find his home in the House. There Hyde earned the respect and admiration of his Democratic and Republican colleagues for his exceptional wisdom, wit, intelligence, rhetorical skill, generosity, and gallantry.
While Hyde’s familiar greeting to visitors, “Welcome to DuPage County, the garden spot of the galaxy,” betrayed a devotion to his district, he never neglected the national interest. Or the international interest. He spent much of his final years in Congress helping turn the tide against AIDS in Africa as chairman of what was then known as the House International Relations Committee. For his cumulative body of work, Hyde was awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom, our nation’s highest civilian honor. He was also knighted by the Pope.
Unlike so many of today’s politicians, Hyde did not run for office to play pundit on cable television or social media. He ran to achieve great things on behalf of the people. His crowning achievement came before his freshman term in Congress ended. It was the bipartisan amendment, bearing his name, barring the use of federal taxpayer funds for elective abortions. Annually renewed as part of the appropriations process, the Hyde Amendment has saved 2.5 million lives since 1976, according to a recent study by the Charlotte Lozier Institute.
Why was Hyde’s name scraped off a courthouse? “It’s strictly because of the Hyde Amendment and it’s very difficult for so many women to walk into the courthouse and see [Hyde’s name],” said Conroy. Really? Recent polling shows that 57% of Americans oppose taxpayer-funded abortion, including 54% of women. Traditionally, the Hyde Amendment has enjoyed broad bipartisan support in Congress. It was supported by Illinoisans as diverse as Ronald Reagan and Barack Obama. Under Conroy’s logic, anything in the state named after those two presidents should also be renamed.
But logic is not Conroy’s strong suit. Nor can it be found among the growing number of Democratic officeholders who, to their eternal discredit, simultaneously claim that abortion is a personal choice and demand that other people pay for it. To counter such incoherence, Rep. Christopher Smith (R-NJ) has introduced legislation to codify the Hyde Amendment, thereby obviating the need for its annual reauthorization.
Over one thousand mourners attended Hyde’s funeral in 2007. Among the dozens of members of Congress in attendance were then-Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) and her successor Rep. John Boehner (R-OH). Of his late colleague, Boehner said “From the streets of his hometown here in Illinois to the halls of Congress, his words and deeds will echo for decades to come.” Since most legislators are forgotten after their term in office, the decision by Conroy and company to remove Hyde’s name from a public building nearly two decades after his death is a kind of perverse tribute to Hyde’s legacy. And as disrespectful to his memory and deleterious to political comity as their actions might be, the truth is Henry Hyde does not need any more monuments. He already has 2.5 million of them.
Paul F. Petrick is an attorney in Cleveland, Ohio.
